The Weeks in Cocoa and Chocolate – Oct 5 - 18, 2019

The Weeks in Cocoa and Chocolate – Oct 5 - 18, 2019

Disclaimers: 1) The day does not represent when the story was originally published, it’s when it came to my attention. 2) I may or may not have done any fact-checking or additional research. 3) DMCA/Fair Use/Parody alert: all opinions expressed are my own.

After a week away from my desk – the news is back.


This Issue’s Hot Byte

Bakers Call Nestle White Chocolate Chips Fake in Class Action.

A group of consumers sued the largest food company in the world [recently], accusing it of misleading customers by producing fake white chocolate while passing it off as real. The lead plaintiffs filed a class action against Nestle USA in Santa Cruz County Superior Court, saying the Swiss multinational food conglomerate falsely marketed white chocolate chips as real white chocolate when it’s actually fake white chocolate made with hydrogenated oils. [The plaintiffs] seek an order barring Nestlé from labeling and advertising the product as white chocolate and restitution on claims of unfair competition, false advertising, and violation of the California Consumers Legal Remedies Act. 


What’s important to pay attention to is that no place on the package is the word chocolate used. Just “Premier White Morsels.” The questions appear to be (and IANAL), whether or not a reasonable person would assume the package contained actual white chocolate made according to CFR 21.163.124 without the word chocolate being used on the label, and, does Nestlé rely on consumer confusion to make higher profits.

Specifically according to CFR 21.163.124, “White chocolate contains not less than 20 percent by weight of cacao fat.” As Nestlé’s Premier White Morsels contain no cocoa fat they cannot be labeled white chocolate. And they aren’t. But then, they are not labeled as white chocolate.

The article goes on to falsly claim (still) that real white chocolate is not real chocolate because it does not contain any cocoa solids. If a chocolate product is made according to the specs in CFR 21.163.124 it can legally be called “white chocolate” in the US, since 2004.. And, lecithin is not “the fatty emulsifier that holds the whole thing together.” That statement reveals a complete misunderstanding of the role of lecithin in chocolate making.


Saturday: New Mexico Professor Traces Chocolate’s Ancient Path

One pottery sherd at a time, archaeologist Patricia Crown has been working to unravel the mystery of chocolate and its importance to a civilization that once inhabited Chaco Canyon (New Mexico), believed to be a ceremonial and economic hub for indigenous people in what is now the American Southwest. Her discoveries over the last decade have shed more light on the widespread use of cacao across the region and the extent of early trade routes with Mesoamerica. But, she says, when it comes to Chaco, each discovery leads only to more questions that archaeologists and anthropologists need to answer.

Hot Take

Many people are flabbergasted to hear that cacao was traded as far north as this in pre-Hispanic times.

Just another astonishing insight into how valued cacao was to ancient peoples in the Americas.

Found at US News Civic.

Sunday: Is white chocolate delicious or disgusting?

“No matter where you fall in this debate, most will agree white chocolate is the most controversial of dessert items. Some chocolate-lovers are staunchly against this pale imposter, pointing out that it’s technically not chocolate. As a result, the milky byproduct tastes like the bottom of a shoe. Others argue white chocolate is a beautiful concoction, perfect for the likes of peppermint bark, cheesecakes, and fruit. Is white chocolate good or bad?

Hot Take

I do agree that white chocolate is a quite controversial topic, but, again, white chocolate is a real thing – it is, technically, chocolate. As soon as the nay-sayers realize this the sooner we can move on to discuss controversial issues that are real.

Also, as with many things in this world there are good examples of white chocolate and disgusting examples. I would point people to El Rey’s multiple award-winning white chocolate, Icoa, which is made with undeodorized cocoa butter as an example of how good white chocolate can be. At the Dallas Chocolate Festival last month I tasted some white chocolates from Zak’s and Xocolla, both small makers pressing their own cocoa butter, that were also very good. You can even find white chocolate made with goat’s milk – Askinosie makes one with pistachio inclusions.

The keys to a good white chocolate are 1) good cocoa butter – and useing undeodorized butter which has a strong cocoa aroma and flavor helps a lot; and 2) the milk that is used – better milk means better white (and milk) chocolate. 

Found at

Monday: UN chocolate bar aims to tackle poverty in the cocoa sector

“The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the FairChain Foundation have created The Other Bar, a chocolate bar that challenges consumers to take direct action against poverty. Launching on Oct. 14, this experiment pilots a new way of doing business with producers in the developing world. Farmers only get 3 percent of the value of the cocoa used to make the chocolate sold in shops, which leads to the majority of cocoa farmers not earning living incomes. The Other Bar ensures farmers are paid prices that meet real income needs — and they receive it faster.”

Hot Take

From the article “Available in milk or dark chocolate, The Other Bar is made from pure, organic Ecuadorian cocoa. Each pack contains two 50-gram bars. A limited-edition 20,000 first run of The Other Bar, priced at £2.99 ($3.68), will go on sale online at on Oct. 14.”

The 3% figure is one that cannot be substantiated (other studies place it as high as 6% – still too low) and may refer to industrial producers. Certainly, one impetus for the craft chocolate movement is to change the economics of chocolate to the benefit of farmers.

One way to read the statement is that the partners in the project are not fully committed to it. This is a pilot and, presumably, if sales do not meet expectations or more people prefer to reward themselves over farmers, its future is at stake. Furthermore, the partners and manufacturers do not appear to be directly rewarding the farmers. There, it’s business as usual and the actual doing good is left to the consumer. #Greenwashing, much?   

Found at CandyIndustry.

Tuesday: Dark chocolate not shown to benefit retinal blood flow, visual function vs. milk chocolate

“Study participants who consumed flavanol-rich dark chocolate experienced no beneficial effects in retinal perfusion or visual function compared with those who consumed milk chocolate. The randomized, controlled, masked double-blind crossover study included 22 participants with normal binocular function and no ocular disease. Each participant consumed either 20 g of flavanol-rich dark chocolate, totaling 400 mg flavanol intake, or 7.5 g milk chocolate, with a total flavanol amount of approximately 5 mg.”

Hot Take

From the article: “Compared with milk chocolate, dark chocolate consumption had no significant improvements in retinal vessel density [snip] … Compared with milk chocolate, there were no statistically significant differences in secondary outcomes for dark chocolate.”

So, there’s less to chocolate than meets the eye?

Found at Healio.

Wednesday: REVIEW: Nestle Toll House Edible Cookie Dough

“Nestle Toll House Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Monster Edible Cookie Dough is made with 100% real chocolate, 100% real peanuts, 100% real rolled oats, 100% real semi-sweet mini gems, and 100% real hydrogenated rapeseed and cottonseed oils, among other things of varying degrees of realness. […] All of that said, Nestle Toll House’s Edible Cookie Dough manages to be simultaneously tasty and lackluster. It simply doesn’t hold up to eating actual raw cookie dough – salmonella and all. I will never listen to Nestle and eat anything edible ever again.”


Hot Take

I have to say I love the attitude of the reviewer, perhaps best exemplified by the following lines:

“100% real hydrogenated rapeseed and cottonseed oils, among other things of varying degrees of realness.” and

“One thing they did do to it is make it look like a (poop emoji).” and

“It simply doesn’t hold up to eating actual raw cookie dough – salmonella and all. I will never listen to Nestle and eat anything edible ever again.”

Read the full review at JunkBanter.

Thursday: Milk Company Chocolate Milk Wins 2nd Place at the World Dairy Expo

“Shatto Milk Company’s Chocolate Milk received second place in the world designation in the Whole Chocolate Milk Class Category during the 2019 World Dairy Exposition Product Judging. This recognition comes less than a year since Shatto’s Garlic Butter was named best in show at the Missouri State fair, 1st place at the World Dairy Expo, and awarded second place at the American Cheese Societies Annual Competition in the category of flavored butters.”

Hot Take

Apparently, this chocolate milk scored 99.9 on a 100 point scale. What does a 100/100 chocolate milk taste like, and how do you differentiate to 1 part in 1000?

Found at PerishableNews.

Friday: Stakeholders decry $493m untapped cocoa potential

From the article, ”Agric stakeholders have decried the current failure of the country to exploit the untapped $493 million potential in the cocoa industry. The National Coordinator, LUGAVO and Women Leader, All Farmers Association of Nigeria (AFAN), Halima Njobdi, in a chat with this newspaper, explained that Nigeria was not doing enough to shore up its cocoa production as well as boost its global cocoa presence. [Snip] According to [Njobdi], Nigeria is blessed with huge deposit of cocoa, which could catapult the country’s non-oil sector.”

Hot Take

“Nigeria is blessed with huge deposit of cocoa.”

I am sorry, no. Cocoa grows on trees in the present day. There was no cocoa in Africa millions of years ago that somehow got ‘deposited’, as oil is.

Source: New Telegraph Nigeria.


More Stories to Ponder

  • The true price of chocolate. Tony’s Chocolonely brings slavery-free chocolate to raise consciousness. (The Tech / Arts / Food Truck Review.)
  • The Queen is ‘a chocoholic’ claims former royal chef – but it has to be dark as she’s ‘not a fan of milk or white.’ Quote, “Apparently, the Queen’s top choice is Bendicks Bittermints – dark chocolate treats filled with mint, which were also given a Royal Warrant in 1962.”
  • Slow Cooker Chocolate Milk French Toast (@ SimplyRecipes). Quotable, “Love chocolate milk? Love french toast? Then you’ll love cozying up with a slice of this simple slow cooker breakfast casserole just as much as we do!” In essence, bread pudding made with a custard using chocolate milk. What’s not to like? Pro Tip: One way to make the recipe better is to make your own chocolate milk by using a good cocoa powder and plain milk.

File it under #greenwashing #ediblecookiedough #HerMajesty

Archived Comments
You've successfully subscribed to The Chocolate Life
Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to The Chocolate Life
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.
Success! Your billing info is updated.
Billing info update failed.